As technology advances and algorithms become increasingly commonplace, the ethical implications of their use become more important to understand. Instagram’s algorithm is no exception—it has the potential to significantly shape our online experience, potentially leading to ethical considerations that must be taken into account. In this article, we’ll explore the ethical implications of Instagram’s algorithm, from understanding the impact of its decisions to analyzing the effects of targeted advertising on users’ behavior.
This article is a part of our series: Understanding the Instagram Algorithm: A Comprehensive Guide
Previous article: How the Instagram Algorithm Can Help Small Businesses Grow
Understanding the Impact of Instagram’s Algorithm
The algorithm used by Instagram is designed to maximize engagement as well as content discovery—in other words, it’s meant to make sure that users interact with the platform, while also showing them content they might find interesting. The algorithm works by taking into account factors such as user preferences, interactions with other users, content posted by those users, and even data from external sources.
Given the amount of data that the algorithm takes into account, it has the potential to shape experiences significantly—from who we follow and interact with, to what type of content we’ll be shown. While this may create more engaging experiences for users, it’s also important to consider the potential harms that can arise from automated decision making. For example, there are concerns about whether the algorithm could reinforce existing biases and discrimination.
Analyzing the Benefits and Risks of Algorithmic Decision Making
The benefits of automated decision making are clear: it can improve the user experience, making it more engaging and efficient. But with great power comes great responsibility—the potential risks must also be considered. For example, algorithms have been found to exhibit a bias towards certain groups or types of users, creating a unequal platform where certain voices are amplified while others are sidelined. This could lead to an increasingly homogenous online experience, where only certain perspectives and voices are visible.
Other potential risks include the possibility of creating a “filter bubble”, where users become increasingly isolated within a small worldview, only seeing content that aligns with their own preferences and views. This could lead to absolutist views and a narrowing of perspectives.
Examining the Role of Social Media Companies in Regulating Algorithms
Given the potential risks of automated decision making, it’s important to consider the role of social media companies in regulating algorithms. While companies should be free to innovate and experiment when it comes to algorithms, there’s a need for oversight and accountability in order to ensure that ethical considerations are taken into account. This is especially true for algorithms with significant impacts on our lives, including those that have potential implications for marginalized or disadvantaged groups.
Social media companies have a responsibility to ensure that algorithms aren’t reinforcing existing biases and discrimination, while also providing transparency and accountability so users can understand how the algorithm is working. Companies should also ensure that mechanisms are put in place to provide redress when algorithmic decisions create negative impacts on individuals or groups.
Investigating the Effects of Targeted Advertising on User Behavior
As well as ethical considerations relating to algorithmic decision making, it’s important to consider the effects of targeted advertising on user behavior. Targeted advertising has become increasingly commonplace on social media platforms, with advertisers using sophisticated techniques to show users content that is tailored to their interests and preferences. While this can provide a more personalized experience for users, there are concerns about how this data can be used to manipulate users based on their behavior.
It’s also important to consider how targeted advertising can lead to reinforcement of certain attitudes and behaviors—for example, research has shown that targeted advertising related to diet productscan lead to unhealthy habits in users who don’t usually exhibit these behaviors.
Exploring Public Perception of Instagram’s Algorithm
As well as looking specifically at the ethical implications of Instagram’s algorithm, it’s also important to consider public perception—especially since its use affects millions of people around the world. Research shows that users generally view algorithms positively—they feel that they provide a better online experience and are an effective tool for content discovery—but there are also concerns about issues such as privacy and transparency.
Users also have concerns about how algorithms can infringe on their autonomy—for example, they don’t feel they have control over what content they’re shown and what posts are highlighted in their feed. This lack of control coupled with the potential for algorithmic decision making to shape our online experience in unintended ways, makes exploring public perception an important part of examining the ethical implications of Instagram’s algorithm.
Assessing the Potential for Ethical Violations in Automated Systems
In addition to considering public perception around algorithms and understanding the potential harms of their use, it’s also important to assess the potential for ethical violations within automated systems. While many ethical violations are already illegal under existing laws, other problems may arise from automated decision making which cannot be addressed through existing regulations.
For example, there have been reports of online platforms using automated decision making to censor certain videos and block certain users—in some cases erroneously—creating potential implications for freedom of expression. There is also potential for algorithmic decision making to lead to discrimination or unfair treatment of marginalized groups, creating further ethical considerations.
Examining the Need for Transparency and Accountability in Automated Decision Making
To mitigate some of the ethical issues related to automated decision making, it’s essential that platforms such as Instagram provide transparency and accountability. Users should be able to easily understand how decisions are made by algorithms and should be given access to some level of control over what is shown in their feeds. Companies should also be required to provide clear explanations when decisions are made which could have negative impacts on individual or groups.
Furthermore, it’s essential that companies have mechanisms in place to provide redress when algorithmic decisions create negative or unintended consequences. This could include providing ways for users to appeal decisions or even compensation where appropriate.
Identifying Strategies for Mitigating Ethical Dilemmas in Social Media Platforms
Finally, social media companies should develop strategies to mitigate ethical dilemmas within their platforms. This could include putting in place codes of ethics that outline responsible uses of algorithms, as well as developing best practices for feedback and monitoring processes for algorithmic decision making. It’s also increasingly important for companies to hire ethical experts who can assess emerging technologies and develop strategies for responsible innovation.
By understanding the ethical implications of their platforms and taking steps to mitigate potential harms, social media companies can ensure that algorithms are used responsibly—and take a step towards protecting their users from the potential harms of automated decision making.
Evaluating the Role of Government Regulation in Technology Governance
In addition to social media companies taking responsibility for ensuring that algorithms are used responsibly on their platforms, there is an increasing need for governments to regulate emerging technologies in order to protect citizens from unethical practices. To ensure that ethical standards are met across all sectors, governments should put laws in place which require companies using algorithms to be transparent about how they make decisions and provide ways for users to appeal or challenge these decisions if necessary.
Governments should also ensure that ethical considerations are taken into account when developing policies around technology and automation. By putting safeguards in place to protect citizens from potential harms related to unethical practices in algorithmic decision making, governments can help ensure that technology is used responsibly and ethically.
By exploring the ethical implications of Instagram’s algorithm, this article has shown how automated decision making has both potential benefits and risks. It has highlighted how social media companies must take responsibility for regulating algorithms on their platform, as well as considering public perception around algorithmic decision making. It has also examined strategies for mitigating ethical dilemmas within social media platforms, and evaluating the role of government regulation in technology governance.
As algorithms become an increasingly integral part of our lives, it’s essential that we consider their implications carefully, ensuring that ethical considerations are taken into account.
When You Are Ready, There Are 3 Ways I Can Help:
1 – If you’re looking to further improve & grow your social media using analytics, I’d recommend starting with a course:
➡️ Analytics for Content Creators: In development, but register your interest using the form below
2 – If you’re more hands off and would like us to audit your Instagram account:
➡️ 1:1 Instagram Account Audit: In development, but register your interest using the form below
3 – Promote yourself to over 140k+ followers/subscribers by collaborating with me on a project!